Wednesday, March 23, 2005

A Spectacular Dive, And A Stunning Swift Climb

The extraordinary performance of ERHC Energy (OTC BB symbol: ERHE) on Tuesday will become folklore as this company moves forward. A massive selloff sparked by a news article in The Punch of Nigeria was dramatically stopped and then almost completely reversed, in one of the most stunning, action-filled spikes investors have ever seen - and resilient ERHE investors have seen it all.

The events began with the appearance of an article early Tuesday evening New York time in the Nigerian daily The Punch. The two authors reported on a statement purportedly from Nigeria-Sao Tome and Principe Joint Development Authority chairman Carlos Gomes of Sao Tome, relayed to them through a mid-level JDA official named Sam Obiora, whom investors had not heard of before.

Obiora told the two reporters, they said, that ExxonMobil had been granted an extension of time to April 19 in which to make two choices in the five blocks on offer to exercise their 25 percent preferential rights in the JDZ. Based on that report, ERHC On The Move, lacking other information, decided that it was wiser to sell and recover profits before buying back in at a lower price, and well after midnight we entered a sell order for 50,000 shares at $0.685.

Staing up all night, we searched Nigerian newspapers and magazines for more information, and finally found it buried in a short article not accessible from the main page or even the main business page of This Day Online.

There, according to reporter Mike Oduniyi, we heard a differing account that originated with the JDA over the weekend in which awards would only be delayed until next week by the apparent failure of ExxonMobil to exercise their rights within a supposed 30-day deadline.

This informaion was found well after 3am EST, and the search went on until dawn. At about 9am, we got a call from a regular reader who informed us that an email was waiting for us that had originated with the JDA's official spokesman, Sam Dimka, in which Dimka stated flatly that the article in The Punch was wrong. Based on that, at about 9:05am EST we cancelled all our sell orders, and waited for the opening bell with some confidence and a lot of anxiety.

Here's the way we saw it: First, we believed the article in The Punch was essentially correct, although perhaps not about the April 19 date when ExxonMobil had to make its choices. In fact, Sam Dimka's notes affirmed, the actual date was April 9.

To our mind, both dates were a disappointment after the high expectations that awards would come this week, but the psychological impact of a new 30-day delay was far more harsh than that of the new "official" deadline, April 9. We felt that the new evidence produced by orangeandwhite0 and ArtK4K when coupled with the article by Oduniyi and a new conversation between orangeandwhite0 and a different JDA official would blunt the impact of The Punch article.

It also raised a bright new possibility: With a two-week delay until April 9, the strong buying interest that has characterized ERHE trading for more than a week would be allowed to continue and carry the share price to a substantial high before the awards. We cancelled our sell order with some trepidation, but by then we believed that the plunge would be short-lived and somewhere in the $0.06 range.

The opening bell brought an immediate and dramatic selloff, with more than 500,000 shares selling in the first minute. The price fell rapidly, hitting $0.645, a loss of $0.06 and $7,380 for our portfolio of 123,040 shares.

As the morning progressed and the four new pieces of information from This Day and the JDA became available, they began to have the desired effect. The price started recovering, and by 3pm EST a trend towards yesterday's highs was becoming pronounced. At the end of the day, the ERHE stood at $0.695, just a cent off after one of the worst scares investors have gotten so far. Volume topped 3.3 million shares, about two-thirds of it on the down side.

As wiser heads have opined, newspaper articles should not be uncritically accepted, and according to Sam Dimka's notes the Punch article was substantially closer to the truth than the This Day article. In fact, I see little that bars ExxonMobil from delaying as long as they like, despite all the protests, and yet I am persuaded that the initial legal terms of the licensing round are still intact.

But the underlying message of Tuesday's incredible performance is that ERHE is a winner. It has solid rights guaranteed by treaty, and it has no debt. It will be awarded its options and possibly one or more operatorships, and a few weeks here or there - or even a few months in an investment that still will take years to mature, is nearly meaningless beside the prospect of stunning gains over the coming months.

One other note: For the first time on Monday, and then again on Tuesday, ERHC On The Move welcomed more than 2,000 readers each day. Yesterday's deep anxiety was evident in the fact that only two readers took time to click on ads, earning us a total of $0.07 for a day and night of hard work. Nonetheless, with the help of Sam Dimka, and especially the efforts of orangeandwhite0 and ArtK4K, we saved our investments and won the day - and that's what really counts.

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

I am anxious for the EEZ's to get started. That will be a much more simplified process as opposed to the JDZ.

Especially due to the fact that we have rights to 2 100% blocks. We wont have to deal with the likes of Exxon holding everyone else hostage.

Anonymous said...

No press release from the JDA yet?

Anonymous said...

Just clicked you 14 cents.

Anonymous said...

"We'll see" is the quote of the day. The JDA I believe is very well intentioned. But the follow through on things is a bit questionable. This process is supposed to be transparent so it is important that they make an official statement regarding any deadline that has been imposed on Exxon.

The twenty or so other companies that are involved in the bidding deserve to know where this process stands via official word. (We tend to think ERHE is the only one waiting but there are other companies waiting as well.)

I believe the JDA will start running into some serious legal issues as will Exxon with these other companies if they continue to allow things to drag out.

Anonymous said...

The key question is does the JDA have the "legal authority" to force Exxon to make a decision.

If so then we will see awards shortly.

If not then this could drag out for quite some time if Exxon decides to play hardball.

Anonymous said...

Arthur I hope you are right. I hope everything is in writing. Because I would imagine that Exxon has a very slick team of lawyers who could maneuver their way through just about anything.

Anonymous said...

Personally I hope exxon decides not to exercise. I would not want them in a block with ERHE. IMHO they would continue to drag things down after awards.

Anonymous said...

Thank you for this site, it is much more concise in the information than the bulletin boards. I have found good information all over the web, but this one nicely pulls it together.

I am interested in what basis there is for the valuations people are throwing out there, since I have not seen a supported valuation at all. If I take the IMF estimates of cashflow stream for EHRE and adjust for $53/BBL oil from the time of their initial $73M per year esitmate (2003, then $25/BBL) that gives me a current valuation of $1.08 per share, which I would assume does not include the value of any operating position so it is a low base. That assumes a 20% expected rate of return and 700,000,000 outstanding shares. Thoughts?

Anonymous said...

A valuation is more difficult to do with ERHE because it is a unique situation which has never been seen in the oil and gas industry. So you cant use a cookie cutter approach when determining the true value of this stock. Any true valuation must take into account the prolific amount of oil reserves which are estimated to be in the blocks which ERHE has percentages in. Here is a quote from the 10-Q to give you an idea of the amount of oil which is estimated to exist their.

"Interpretation carried out by WesternGeco has enabled the identification of 56 prospective structures within Blocks 1 to 9 in the JDZ, of which 17 were defined as prospects and 39 as leads. WesternGeco used reservoir parameters similar to those known from nearby fields in Nigeria and Equatorial Guinea. Combined recoverable reserves potential of the 17 prospects was estimated by WesternGeco to be 14.4 billion barrels of oil. The scope of the WesternGeco report was to interpret and map seismic data, highlight prospectivity and calculate volumetrics."

Anonymous said...

For a different route of valuation, go look at Afren:
http://today.reuters.co.uk/stocks/Quote.aspx?symbol=AFR.L
Afren is a new IPO that owns 4.41% of block 1. Compare round 1 signature bonuses between blocks for an assessment of relative amounts of oil in each block. If you follow the math, ERHC -sans STP EEZ- has about 16-fold the valuation of Afren. This works out to $2.80 or so a share for ERHC (no EEZ). Obviously this valuation uses the formulas that others used to value Afren, probably pretty reasonable, though. A run-down on this is under pinecat in RB, or is given as a file in EF. The other approach is by mabenn1 and is also listed as a file in EF. Mabenn1 comes to about the same price, but uses approximate barrels of potential oil at a value of $1/barrel.

Anonymous said...

I began buying into ERHC after belatedly reading the 03/18 Houston Chronicle piece, which was passed on by a friend. That's also where I discovered your "On the Move" blog, which I've since been reading with interest. This is my first experience of an investment "chat" forum, so I have everything to learn.

Query: In simple language, please, why is XOM´s decision SO VITAL to ERHC's future?

Looking forward to learning from one or more responses, though Father Joe's would be especially appreciated.

Bests,
Homeport

Anonymous said...

should see furthur selling pressure tomorrow as chart indicates. 30 day MA is .57.

Anonymous said...

It's not that XOM is vital to ERHE'S future it's that they won't release the results for blocks 2-6 until XOM has chose its 2x25% stakes in these blocks. Once they have chosen then we find out just what ERHE ends up with. We know that ERHE already has a stake in each one of the remaining blocks, but we are looking forward to seeing if they end up with operatorship in one or more, maybe as many as 3.

Anonymous said...

Thank you Anonymous and Anonymous for the information on the valuations. The Aref information is a little sparse, but I found all I could.

If the charter has it right and it pushes to .57 that should be a good opportunity to add more shares, though there has been a lot of support at higher prices so I don't see it.

Anonymous said...

If no news comes out of the JDA and no deadline is enforced we all will be thankful if ERHE holds up at .57.

This is a very simple story right now. If we get awards the price will go up. If we dont the stock will drop.

If there is clarification in the form of a news release then the stock will go up. If there are empty promises and missed deadlines the stock will go down.

If the JDA is truly running the show and has the ultimate power the stock will go up. If Exxon has the power and stalls this out then the stock will go down.

Exxon is screwing this whole process up. If they are allowed to get away with it this round will be in serious trouble.

ERHE might actually end up with the Sao Tome EEZ selections before the JDZ is concluded. Unless of course Exxon gets third pick in the EEZ.

...Joe Shea said...

Homeport, welcome to the blog. I appreciate your readership!

The only reason XOM's choice is so important is that we can't get our awards until their issues are disposed of; until they decide if and where they want to exercise their two 25 percent preferential options, the JDA can't determine any operatorships. We hope to get operatorships along with our preferential options (we've already exercised), so the choices XOM makes may help determine whether we do or not (and may not be determinative, too). Most of us expect that immediately upon XOM's de4cision being communicated to the JDA, the Joint Ministerial XCouncil will be convened and announce awards within a few days. All during that time, we think, the share price will be rocketing higher each day. I hope this answers your question - I don't usually try.